Gelephu and the Lhotshampa Connection
From BhutanWiki, the people's encyclopedia of Bhutan · history · Verified
Gelephu is a town in Sarpang District, southern Bhutan, that has become the site of the planned Gelephu Mindfulness City (GMC), a Special Administrative Region announced in December 2023. Its reported area varies by source, from 1,000 square kilometres (ABC News, 2024)[11] to the "4,000-square-kilometre startup" described by Prime Minister Tshering Tobgay at the UN General Assembly in 2026;[12] the GMC Authority's website gives over 4,046 square kilometres.[35] Long before the announcement, Gelephu held deep historical significance for the Lhotshampa community — the ethnic Nepali population of southern Bhutan. Originally known by the Nepali name "Hatisar," the town was a major centre of Lhotshampa settlement, commerce, and agriculture until the forced expulsions of the late 1980s and 1990s. The development of a mega-city on this land, without resolution of outstanding property claims or acknowledgment of the displacement, has become one of the most contested aspects of the GMC project.
Historical Settlement and Naming
People of Nepali origin began settling in the uninhabited lowlands of southern Bhutan in the 19th century, drawn by the fertile subtropical terrain. By 1930, British colonial officials estimated that approximately 60,000 people of Nepali origin were cultivating the southern belt.[1] The Gelephu area, situated on a low-lying alluvial plain at the India-Bhutan border, was part of this Lhotshampa settlement zone.
The original settlement was known as Hatisar (also written "Hati Sahar"), derived from the Nepali words hatti (elephant) and sahar (town or place), meaning "elephant place" — a reference to the wild Asian elephants that inhabited the subtropical lowlands. In the 1960s, the settlement was relocated from the banks of the Mo Chhu to its present location.[2]
In 1959, under the third King Jigme Dorji Wangchuck's policy of establishing Bhutanese-language place names across the country, the town was renamed Gaylegphug (later simplified to Gelephu). According to oral tradition, Lopen Nyapchhi, the storekeeper of the third King, played a key role in coining new names for the frontier towns, including Gelephu.[3] The renaming was part of a broader pattern of replacing Nepali and other non-Dzongkha place names in southern Bhutan with names drawn from the dominant Ngalop linguistic tradition. Critics view this as an early expression of the cultural assimilation policies that would later intensify into the "one nation, one people" campaign of the late 1980s.
By the 1980s, Gelephu had developed into a thriving commercial town. Lhotshampa families owned businesses, agricultural land, and properties. The town contained landmarks associated with its multicultural character, including the Ashok Hotel and Losal Cinema Hall, both reportedly Lhotshampa-owned.[4]
The 1990s Expulsions from Sarpang
Beginning in the late 1980s, the Bhutanese government implemented a series of policies that led to the forced displacement of over 100,000 Lhotshampa from southern Bhutan — approximately one-seventh of the country's population at the time. The expulsions were precipitated by the 1985 Citizenship Act, the 1988 census in southern districts, and the "one nation, one people" cultural policy that mandated Ngalop dress codes, Dzongkha language use, and cultural uniformity.
Sarpang District, where Gelephu is located, was among the most heavily affected areas. The Nepali language, spoken by the majority in Sarpang, was removed from schools in 1989. Anti-government protests erupted in southern Bhutan in 1990, met by a security crackdown. Over the following years, Lhotshampa in Sarpang and other southern districts were subjected to:
- Retroactive reclassification as "non-nationals" through census re-evaluations
- Requirement to produce citizenship documentation dating to 1958 or earlier
- Coerced signing of "voluntary migration forms" under duress
- Confiscation of land, homes, businesses, and personal property
- Harassment, arbitrary detention, and in some cases physical violence by security forces
Those expelled crossed into India and ultimately settled in UNHCR-administered refugee camps in eastern Nepal. By the mid-1990s, over 100,000 Bhutanese refugees were registered in seven camps in Jhapa and Morang districts of Nepal.[5]
Land Confiscation in the Gelephu Area
Lhotshampa expelled from the Gelephu area left behind substantial property. In a March 2025 article for Sapan News, Suraj Budathoki, a former refugee and New Hampshire state representative, recorded the account of Hari Adhikari, a National Assembly member from Gelephu between 1977 and 1983. Adhikari said his family lost about 14 acres of farmland, the three-storey Ashok Hotel, a grocery store and three homes, and that "we received no compensation". The article states that nearly 16 acres were seized within Gelephu municipality in 1990.[4] In his own later valuation, reported by The Diplomat in October 2026, Adhikari put his family's lost property, business assets and foregone income at Nu 29.4 million at 1990 prices.[13] Another former resident, Shiva Lal Adhikari, told Budathoki he was paid Nu 7,000 (about USD 80, the article's conversion) for his land and home and accepted it under duress; this is one family's account rather than a documented general rate.[4]
Bhutanese law at the time provided for the state to take such property. Section 6(e) of the Citizenship Act 1985 required anyone deprived of citizenship to dispose of all immovable property within one year, "failing which, the immovable property shall be confiscated by the Ministry of Home Affairs on payment of fair and reasonable compensation".[14] Section 127 of the Land Act 2007 provides that the land of a citizen who has migrated to another country, without first applying to transfer it, "shall be taken over as the Government land or Government Reserved Forests land".[15] Human Rights Watch, citing Amnesty International's 1994 report Bhutan: Forcible Exile, wrote that some refugees received money for their land but that "frequently the compensation represented only a fraction of the value of the land".[16] No government record of compensation paid to Gelephu families has been published.
Some displaced families retained documentation of their land holdings, and the two Nepal-based sources on this point give different figures. Nepali Times reported in December 2024 that "eleven of the households even have their land holding titles".[8] Kanak Mani Dixit, citing refugee leaders in Scroll.in in April 2025, wrote that 11 per cent of the Gelephu-origin refugees remaining in Nepal hold deeds for property in the area.[17] No restitution or compensation process has been established for such title holders.
Resettlement on vacated land
Domestic and exile sources describe the post-expulsion settlement of the south in different terms. BBS has reported on a Resettlement Programme begun in 1997 under the Fourth King, which distributed 37,490 acres of "state land" to close to 7,500 households, about five acres each, in five southern dzongkhags including Sarpang.[18] The BBS account does not say who held the land before.
Human Rights Watch reported in 2007 that "following the expulsion of the refugees in the early 1990s, the government resettled Drukpa people from northern Bhutan on land that was formerly owned by the refugees".[19] Ratan Gazmere and Dilip Bishwo of the refugee rights group AHURA Bhutan wrote in Forced Migration Review around 2000 that prime lands in most of the six southern districts had been "reallocated to northerners, most of whom are ex-servicemen and their relatives", and that "strategic and commercially valuable land has been given to senior officials serving the present regime".[20] A Habitat International Coalition fact-finding team, which visited Sarpang from 23 September to 1 October 2001, interviewed 17 refugee families and visited the land of seven of them in Gelephu, Lodrai and Lalai; a summary of its findings published by the exile think tank Bhutan Watch records, among other cases, houses occupied by northern Bhutanese, land occupied by a former dungpa (sub-divisional officer) and land converted into a storehouse for cement poles.[21] The original HIC report has not been located online.
Present-day acquisition for GMC concerns current registered owners. BBS reported that 552 thram (land title) holders with about 1,400 acres in Samtenling gewog would make way for Gelephu International Airport, with replacement land offered in the 19 dzongkhags other than Sarpang, tokenisation or cash.[22] No source has linked these present holdings to land once registered to expelled families.
Current Refugee Population and Gelephu Connections
Of the approximately 113,500 Bhutanese refugees resettled through the UNHCR's Third Country Resettlement Programme between 2007 and 2016, the largest number — approximately 96,000 — went to the United States. Nepali Times reported in December 2024 that about 6,577 people from Bhutan remained in eastern Nepal, primarily in the Beldangi and Pathri camps. UNHCR and the World Food Programme withdrew support from the camps in 2016, leaving residents without institutional assistance.[8]
Estimates of the Gelephu share come from refugees themselves. Tankanath Bhujel, a 70-year-old camp resident, told Inkstick Media in November 2024 that "around 40% of the Beldangi camp residents are from Gelephu".[9] Nepali Times wrote that at least 40 per cent of those remaining "are said to be from Gelephu",[8] and Dixit gave the same proportion for the roughly 7,000 refugees he described as remaining in Nepal.[17] Krishna Bir Tamang, who coordinates the camp-based National Reconciliation Committee, told Inkstick that 2,340 camp residents want to be repatriated.[9] No repatriation agreement between Bhutan and Nepal has been implemented.
Krishna Bir Tamang, a 54-year-old refugee who has lived in Nepal for over 30 years after being expelled from southern Bhutan, told the South China Morning Post: "We still have our land there and possess legal documents." He chose not to participate in third-country resettlement, stating: "We didn't resettle in a third country because we are bona fide citizens of Bhutan."[7]
The Moral and Legal Question
The development of GMC on land from which an ethnic community was forcibly expelled raises legal and moral questions that have been articulated by human rights organisations and refugee advocates:
Property restitution under international law: The international standard most often cited is the Pinheiro Principles, formally the Principles on Housing and Property Restitution for Refugees and Displaced Persons (UN Doc. E/CN.4/Sub.2/2005/17), endorsed by the UN Sub-Commission on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights in 2005. They state that refugees have the right to have restored to them property of which they were "arbitrarily or unlawfully deprived", or to be compensated where restoration is factually impossible, and that this right is "prejudiced neither by the actual return nor non-return" of the refugees.[23] The Principles are soft law rather than a treaty and do not bind Bhutan of their own force. Diaspora writers, including Budathoki, have invoked them and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in arguing for restitution of land in the GMC area.[4]
Treaty obligations and UN review: Bhutan is not party to the 1951 Refugee Convention, and the CEDAW Committee has recommended that it accede.[24] It has ratified the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (1981)[25] and the Convention on the Rights of the Child (1990).[26] In concluding observations dated 14 November 2023, the CEDAW Committee noted structural inequalities faced by ethnic minority women "including in accessing land" and recommended that Bhutan, "in line with its obligation under international law, allow for voluntary return".[27] In June 2024 the Committee on the Rights of the Child, "noting with deep concern the lack of progress in repatriating Lhotshampa children from refugee camps in Nepal", urged Bhutan to work with Nepal "to ensure the return and resettlement" of those children.[28] In its 2024 Universal Periodic Review, Bhutan "noted", and so did not accept, all three recommendations on the Lhotshampa and the refugees in Nepal (129.192, 129.193 and 129.198).[29] None of these documents addresses GMC land specifically, and no UN body is known to have done so.
The "mindfulness" paradox: Multiple commentators have noted what they describe as a fundamental contradiction between the stated philosophy of GMC — built on principles of mindfulness, compassion, and holistic well-being — and the unresolved injustice underlying its physical foundation. Writing in The Baffler, Andre Naffis-Sahely described Bhutan's international image as masking the fact that the country "has largely gotten away with an attempt at ethnic cleansing."[10]
Absence of official acknowledgment: The Bhutanese government has not publicly acknowledged the connection between GMC's location and the 1990s expulsions. The Prime Minister's Office did not respond to media requests for comment regarding the Lhotshampa population's potential inclusion in GMC plans.[9] No property restitution process, truth and reconciliation mechanism, or formal compensation scheme has been proposed.
Diaspora Perspectives
Responses from the Lhotshampa diaspora have been varied. Some, like CB Dahal, have threatened legal action: "We will go to the international court if we have to."[7] Others have expressed interest in taking part. DJ Khaling, a resettled businessman and US citizen, told Inkstick Media he was "particularly interested in the tourism sector of the new Gelephu Mindfulness City", as well as IT, education and healthcare.[9]
Bhutan Watch's 2025 human rights report, as reported by Bhutan News Network, said GMC is being built on land "formerly occupied and cultivated by displaced Lhotshampa families", that it was announced without public consultation or land restitution, and recommended "proper compensation to all the displaced households from the GMC area".[30] In April 2025 the Nepali journalist Kanak Mani Dixit addressed an open letter to King Jigme Khesar Namgyel Wangchuck, as chairman of GMC, asking whether he would "order an investigation" into the land.[17]
Prime Minister Tshering Tobgay presented GMC to the 81st UN General Assembly on 22 September 2026 as "an institutional blank slate", and said of its forests and wildlife that "this is not empty land". The address did not mention refugees or land claims.[12] In The Diplomat on 5 October 2026, the diaspora writers TP Mishra and Ramesh Gautam argued that "the language of a blank slate can obscure the history of the land". They quoted Bhanu Adhikari, 76, of Adelaide, who said that if foreign investors were involved in GMC, "we will try to seek legal counsel to hold them accountable and pursue compensation", and Tilak Rai, chair of the camp-based Bhutanese Refugee Representative Repatriation Committee, who appealed to the international community to prevent Bhutan "from turning seized ancestral land into a high-tech façade designed to erase our history".[13]
Human Rights Watch has twice linked the Prime Minister's investment pitches to political prisoners. In January 2026 it noted that Tobgay was touring Europe seeking investment in GMC while political prisoners remained in jail,[31] and on 21 September 2026 it urged leaders at the General Assembly to press for the release of "at least 28 political prisoners".[32] Neither statement addressed land in the GMC area. Rights organisations including South Asians for Human Rights (SAHR) have called for resolution of the refugee issue.[8]
Return and visits
Community leaders, advocates and researchers say that former refugees have not been allowed to return to Bhutan, even as visitors on foreign passports. Tila Guragain of the Bhutanese Community in Australia Inc. told SBS Nepali in October 2024 that "despite us being Australian citizens, we are barred from entering Bhutan"; the same report described refugee-background Australians as unable to register for the King's community audiences during his 2024 visit, which required Bhutanese citizenship documents.[33] Susan Banki of the University of Sydney wrote that "over the past three decades, not one former refugee has been permitted to return to Bhutan" and urged the King to reopen discussion of travel for refugees.[34] Budathoki wrote that resettled Bhutanese cannot attend the funerals of relatives in Bhutan,[4] and Bhutan Watch's 2025 report recommended that the government "allow resettled Bhutanese with foreign passport to visit Bhutan as tourist to meet their families".[30] No named case of a refused visa has been published, and no Bhutanese government statement of policy on the question has been found.
Comparative Context
GMC is not the first case of commercial development on land associated with population displacement. Neom in Saudi Arabia has been documented to involve the forced eviction of the Howeitat tribe, with death sentences issued to tribal members who resisted displacement. Amaravati, the planned capital of Andhra Pradesh, India, involved contentious land acquisition from farming communities. In each case, the tension between development ambitions and the rights of displaced communities has generated significant criticism.
What distinguishes the Gelephu case is the temporal gap — the displacement occurred three decades ago, and the affected population has been scattered across continents through resettlement — and the rhetorical framing of the development as a centre of mindfulness and compassion, a branding that critics view as incompatible with its unresolved history.
See also
- Lhotshampa: Origins and Settlement in Bhutan
- Forced Eviction of Lhotshampa (1990-1993)
- Lhotshampa Name Reclamation in the Diaspora
- Lhotshampa Marriage Traditions
References
- Lhotshampa — Wikipedia
- Gelephu — Wikipedia
- The Cultural History of Gelephu — Bhutan Watch
- The hidden costs of Bhutan's Gelephug 'mindfulness city' — Sapan News
- Bhutan's Dark Secret: The Lhotshampa Expulsion — The Diplomat
- The Exodus of Ethnic Nepalis from Southern Bhutan — Refworld/WRITENET
- Displaced ethnic Nepalis fume over Bhutan's 'mindfulness city' plan — South China Morning Post
- Mindfulness about Bhutan's refugees — Nepali Times
- What Will Bhutan's Mindfulness City Mean for the Lhotshampa Community? — Inkstick Media
- The Mismeasure of Bhutan — The Baffler
- Will Jackson, "Can Bhutan's plans for a 'mindfulness city' convince its diaspora community to come home?" — ABC News, 3 February 2024
- Bhutan: statement by Prime Minister Tshering Tobgay, General Debate of the 81st Session, 22 September 2026 — United Nations
- TP Mishra and Ramesh Gautam, "Bhutan's 'Mindfulness City' Hides a Dark Reality" — The Diplomat, 5 October 2026
- Bhutan Citizenship Act 1985 (English text), section 6 — Bhutan Media Foundation
- Land Act of Bhutan 2007, section 127 — National Land Commission Secretariat
- Last Hope: The Need for Durable Solutions for Bhutanese Refugees in Nepal and India, chapter III — Human Rights Watch, May 2007
- Kanak Mani Dixit, "In the injustice of Bhutan's 'mindfulness city', a plea to King Jigme Khesar" — Scroll.in, 2 April 2025
- Pema Tshewang and Kinley Wangchuk, "Bhutanese farmers reap fruits of His Majesty the Fourth Druk Gyalpo's visionary Resettlement Programme" — BBS
- Last Hope: The Need for Durable Solutions for Bhutanese Refugees in Nepal and India, chapter V — Human Rights Watch, May 2007
- Ratan Gazmere and Dilip Bishwo, "Bhutanese refugees: rights to nationality, return and property" — Forced Migration Review (c. 2000)
- "Gelephu Beats Inside Bhutanese in Exile", The Bhutan Journal 6(1) — Bhutan Watch, 2025 (includes a summary of the Habitat International Coalition fact-finding mission of 2001)
- Karma Wangdi, "Over 550 landowners in Samtenling Gewog to make way for Gelephu International Airport" — BBS
- Principles on Housing and Property Restitution for Refugees and Displaced Persons (UN Doc. E/CN.4/Sub.2/2005/17) — University of Minnesota Human Rights Library
- Compilation of information prepared by OHCHR: Bhutan, A/HRC/WG.6/47/BTN/2, para. 4 — UN Human Rights Council
- Status of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women — United Nations Treaty Collection
- Status of the Convention on the Rights of the Child — United Nations Treaty Collection
- Concluding observations on the tenth periodic report of Bhutan, CEDAW/C/BTN/CO/10, 14 November 2023, paras. 59–60 — UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women
- Concluding observations on the combined sixth and seventh periodic reports of Bhutan, CRC/C/BTN/CO/6-7, 21 June 2024, para. 42 — UN Committee on the Rights of the Child
- Report of the Working Group on the Universal Periodic Review: Bhutan, Addendum (views on recommendations), A/HRC/58/9/Add.1 — UN Human Rights Council
- "Bhutan Watch releases 2025 Human Rights Report on Bhutan" — Bhutan News Network, 8 June 2025
- Claudio Francavilla, "Bhutan Leader Seeks European Investment as Political Prisoners Languish" — Human Rights Watch, 26 January 2026
- Elaine Pearson, "Bhutan Should Release All Remaining Political Prisoners" — Human Rights Watch, 21 September 2026
- Abhas Parajuli, "Locked out: Bhutan's King is in Australia, but refugees from his country can't meet him" — SBS Nepali, 11 October 2024
- Susan Banki, King of Bhutan can rectify historical injustices — University of Sydney, 14 October 2024
- "Gelephu Mindfulness City." Gelephu Mindfulness City Authority, official website (archived 29 October 2026).
Related articles
Know something about this topic? Edit this article or . Anonymous contributions welcome — no account required.