politics

Penal Code of Bhutan

1202 words

The Penal Code of Bhutan (2004) is the principal criminal statute of the Kingdom of Bhutan, codifying offenses and penalties for the first time in a comprehensive modern legal framework. It includes controversial provisions on homosexuality under Section 213 and has been the subject of ongoing reform discussions.

The Penal Code of Bhutan is the principal criminal statute of the Kingdom of Bhutan, enacted in 2004 by the National Assembly. It represents the first comprehensive codification of criminal law in Bhutan, replacing a patchwork of royal decrees, customary law, and the Thrimzhung Chhenmo (Supreme Law) of 1965 that had previously governed criminal matters. The Penal Code brought Bhutanese criminal law into alignment with modern legal standards while also reflecting the country's Buddhist values and cultural traditions.[1]

The code covers a wide range of criminal offences, from crimes against the state and the person to property crimes, drug offences, and offences against public order and morality. It establishes a graded system of felonies and misdemeanours with specified penalties, introduces the principle of mens rea (criminal intent), and codifies defences and mitigating factors. The code has attracted international attention primarily for its provisions on sexual offences, particularly Section 213 on "unnatural sex", which until 2021 was widely interpreted as applying to homosexual conduct.[1]

Historical Background

Prior to the enactment of the Penal Code, Bhutan's criminal justice system was governed primarily by the Thrimzhung Chhenmo, promulgated by King Jigme Dorji Wangchuck in 1965. The Thrimzhung Chhenmo was Bhutan's first written legal code and covered both civil and criminal matters, but it was not a comprehensive modern criminal statute. Many aspects of criminal law remained governed by custom, judicial discretion, and royal decree. The Thrimzhung Chhenmo reflected a blend of Buddhist legal principles and traditional Bhutanese practices, with an emphasis on compensation and restitution rather than punitive incarceration.[2]

The development of the 2004 Penal Code was part of a broader effort to modernise Bhutan's legal system in anticipation of the transition to constitutional democracy. Beginning in the late 1990s, the Royal Government undertook a systematic review of existing laws and the drafting of new legislation across multiple domains, including civil procedure, evidence, and criminal law. The Penal Code was drafted with technical assistance from international legal experts and underwent review by the National Assembly before its enactment.[3]

Structure and Key Provisions

The Penal Code is organised into chapters covering different categories of offences. Its structure follows a broadly conventional pattern for modern criminal codes, with provisions organised by the gravity of the offence and the protected interest.

Offenses Against the State

The code addresses offences against the sovereignty, security, and dignity of the state, including treason, sedition, espionage, and offences against the person of the King. Given Bhutan's constitutional monarchy, offences against the institution of the monarchy carry severe penalties. The code also covers terrorism-related offences and threats to national security.[3]

Offenses Against the Person

The code comprehensively addresses crimes against the person, including homicide (with distinctions between murder and manslaughter), assault, kidnapping, trafficking in persons, and sexual offences including rape. The code establishes clear gradations of offences based on severity, intent, and circumstances, with penalties ranging from fines to life imprisonment. Bhutan does not impose the death penalty, having abolished it during the Thrimzhung Chhenmo era — a position consistent with Buddhist principles regarding the sanctity of life.[4]

Property Offenses

The code covers theft, robbery, burglary, fraud, forgery, embezzlement, and related property crimes. It also addresses offences related to the destruction of property, arson, and criminal damage. The penalties are calibrated to the value of the property involved and the circumstances of the offence.

Drug Offenses

The Penal Code includes provisions addressing the manufacture, distribution, possession, and consumption of controlled substances. Drug abuse has become an increasing concern in Bhutan, particularly among youth in urban areas, and the code's drug provisions have been supplemented by additional legislation, including the Narcotic Drugs, Psychotropic Substances and Substance Abuse Act.

Section 213: "Unnatural Sex" and Homosexuality

The most internationally discussed provision of the Penal Code is Section 213, which states that "a defendant shall be guilty of the offence of unnatural sex, if the defendant engages in sodomy or any other sexual conduct that is against the order of nature." The offence is classified as a petty misdemeanour, carrying a maximum penalty of one year of imprisonment.[1]

The inclusion of this provision has drawn criticism from international human rights organisations, including Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, and the International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association (ILGA). These organisations have called for the repeal of Section 213, arguing that it violates the rights to privacy, equality, and non-discrimination under international human rights law, including the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, to which Bhutan is not a party but whose principles are reflected in the Constitution of Bhutan.[1]

In practice, there have been no known prosecutions under Section 213, and enforcement of the provision appears to be essentially non-existent. Bhutanese society has traditionally been relatively tolerant of diverse sexual practices in private, and homosexuality has not been the subject of the same degree of public condemnation as in some other South Asian countries. Nevertheless, the existence of the provision on the statute books has a chilling effect on the LGBT community in Bhutan, discouraging openness and limiting access to healthcare and social services.[1]

In 2019 the National Assembly voted to repeal Section 213, and the bill went to the National Council.[5] The National Council kept the section but amended it to provide that "homosexuality between adults shall not be considered unnatural sex". Parliament passed the amendment at a joint sitting in December 2020, and the Penal Code (Amendment) Act became law on 17 February 2021 after receiving royal assent, decriminalising same-sex conduct between adults.[6]

Legal Reforms and Amendments

The Penal Code has been amended several times since its initial enactment in 2004. Amendments have addressed emerging issues such as cybercrime, human trafficking, domestic violence, and child protection. The Child Care and Protection Act of 2011 and the Domestic Violence Prevention Act of 2013 supplemented the Penal Code's provisions on crimes against vulnerable populations, reflecting Bhutan's evolving social priorities and its engagement with international human rights standards.[3]

The broader context of legal reform in Bhutan has been shaped by the 2008 Constitution, which established an independent judiciary, guaranteed fundamental rights including equality before the law, and created a framework for the rule of law that did not exist under the pre-constitutional system. The Penal Code operates within this constitutional framework, and its provisions are subject to constitutional review by the courts.

Significance

The Penal Code of Bhutan 2004 represents a landmark in Bhutanese legal history. For a country that had no written legal code until 1965 and no comprehensive criminal statute until 2004, the code's enactment marked a significant step in the development of a modern, rules-based legal system. Its provisions, while imperfect, replaced a system of largely discretionary justice with one based on codified offences, defined penalties, and procedural safeguards — prerequisites for the rule of law that the 2008 Constitution would later enshrine as a constitutional principle.

References

  1. LGBT rights in Bhutan — Wikipedia
  2. Thrimzhung Chhenmo — Wikipedia
  3. Royal Court of Justice, Bhutan
  4. Capital punishment in Bhutan — Wikipedia
  5. Bhutan: Vote to Decriminalize Same-Sex Relations — Human Rights Watch
  6. "King's assent leads Himalayan nation of Bhutan to become latest country to decriminalise same-sex activity." Human Dignity Trust, 18 March 2021.

View online: https://bhutanwiki.org/articles/penal-code-of-bhutan · Content licensed CC BY-SA 4.0