India–Bhutan Friendship Treaty (1949)

From BhutanWiki, the people's encyclopedia of Bhutan · history · Verified

The Treaty of Perpetual Peace and Friendship between the Government of India and the Government of Bhutan, usually called the India–Bhutan Friendship Treaty of 1949, was signed at Darjeeling on 8 August 1949. It regulated relations between Bhutan and the newly independent Republic of India after the end of British rule, replacing the arrangements of the Treaty of Sinchula (1865) and the Treaty of Punakha (1910). It remained in force until it was replaced by the India–Bhutan Friendship Treaty of 2007.[1][2]

Its best-known clause is Article II, under which India undertook not to interfere in Bhutan's internal administration and Bhutan agreed "to be guided by the advice of the Government of India in regard to its external relations". The treaty also raised India's annual payment to Bhutan to five lakh rupees and returned about thirty-two square miles of territory at Dewangiri, taken by the British after the Duar War.[1]

Background

The preamble describes the treaty's purpose as regulating "the state of affairs caused by the termination of the British Government's authority in India". Under the Treaty of Punakha, Bhutan had agreed to be guided by the British government in its external relations in return for non-interference in its internal affairs, and had received an annual allowance first set under the Treaty of Sinchula. A further temporary subsidy of one lakh rupees a year had been granted in 1942.[1][3]

Signing and ratification

The treaty was signed at Darjeeling on 8 August 1949, which the text gives as the fifteenth day of the sixth month of the Earth-Bull year. Harishwar Dayal, the Political Officer in Sikkim, signed for India. Bhutan was represented by Deb Zimpon Sonam Tobgye Dorji, Yang-Lop Sonam, Chho-Zim Thondup, Rin-Zim Tandin and Ha Drung Jigmie Palden Dorji, acting for the second king, Jigme Wangchuck. The king ratified it at Tongsa on 15 September 1949, and the Governor-General of India, C. Rajagopalachari, at New Delhi on 22 September 1949.[1]

Provisions

The treaty has ten articles:[1]

  • Article I: perpetual peace and friendship between the two governments.
  • Article II: "The Government of India undertakes to exercise no interference in the internal administration of Bhutan. On its part the Government of Bhutan agrees to be guided by the advice of the Government of India in regard to its external relations."
  • Article III: in place of the compensation under Article 4 of the Treaty of Sinchula, as enhanced in 1910, and the 1942 temporary subsidy, India would pay Bhutan five lakh rupees a year, on 10 January each year from 1950, for as long as the treaty remained in force and its terms were observed.
  • Article IV: within one year India would return "about thirty-two square miles of territory in the area known as Dewangiri", and would appoint officers to mark out the area.
  • Article V: free trade and commerce "as heretofore", with facilities for carrying Bhutanese produce through India by land and water, including the use of agreed forest roads.
  • Article VI: Bhutan could import arms, ammunition, machinery and warlike stores from or through India "with the assistance and approval of the Government of India", for as long as India was satisfied that Bhutan's intentions were friendly; Bhutan agreed not to export such material.
  • Article VII: Bhutanese subjects in India and Indian subjects in Bhutan would receive equal justice with local subjects.
  • Article VIII: extradition of persons accused of crimes listed in the Indian Extradition Act, 1903.
  • Article IX: disputes to be settled first by negotiation and, failing agreement within three months, by a tribunal of three arbitrators chaired by a judge of the Federal Court or a High Court in India chosen by Bhutan.
  • Article X: the treaty would continue in force in perpetuity unless terminated or modified by mutual consent.

Return of Dewangiri

Dewangiri, the hill post the British had captured in 1864 and annexed after the Duar War, lies in what is now Samdrup Jongkhar District. The return promised in Article IV was not completed within the year. The strip had not been surveyed or demarcated, and once India's constitution took effect in 1950 the transfer required an Act of Parliament. After the Assam Legislative Assembly recommended the transfer on 27 March 1951, Parliament passed the Assam (Alteration of Boundaries) Act, 1951, which came into force on 1 September 1951. It removed a strip of 32.81 square miles known as Dewangiri from the territory of Assam and ceded it to Bhutan; the Act's statement of objects describes the undertaking as made "by Article 4" of the 1949 treaty.[1][4]

Article II in practice

Article II carried over the British-era formula on external relations. Bhutan nonetheless joined the United Nations in 1971 and built its own diplomatic relations in the following decades (see Bhutan and the United Nations).[3] Whether the clause made Bhutan's foreign policy subject to India's, or only committed it to consultation, was debated for decades; a 2023 working paper by Uttam Lama of the Institute for Social and Economic Change describes Bhutan pressing India to update the treaty, "especially Article 2", until India agreed in 2007.[3]

Replacement in 2007

The India–Bhutan Friendship Treaty was signed in New Delhi on 8 February 2007 and came into force when instruments of ratification were exchanged in Thimphu on 2 March 2007. Its preamble records that the two governments had decided "to update the 1949 Treaty".[2] The main changes were:

  • The "guided by" clause was replaced. The new Article 2 provides that the two governments "shall cooperate closely with each other on issues relating to their national interests" and that neither will allow its territory to be used for activities harmful to the other's national security.
  • The arms clause (now Article 4) no longer requires imports to be made "with the assistance and approval of the Government of India", though it keeps the condition that India be satisfied Bhutan's intentions are friendly.
  • The articles on the annual payment and on Dewangiri, both spent, were not carried over. Free trade, equal justice and extradition were kept, and new articles were added on cultural and economic cooperation.

[2]

See also

References

  1. Treaty of Perpetual Peace and Friendship between the Government of India and the Government of Bhutan, Darjeeling, 8 August 1949, with instruments of ratification. [1949] INTSer 14, CommonLII (archived).
  2. India–Bhutan Friendship Treaty, New Delhi, 8 February 2007. Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India.
  3. Lama, Uttam. India and Bhutan: A Relationship Before and After Independence. ISEC Working Paper 560. Bangalore: Institute for Social and Economic Change, 2023.
  4. The Assam (Alteration of Boundaries) Act, 1951 (Act No. 47 of 1951), with statement of objects and reasons. Indian Kanoon.

Related articles

Know something about this topic? Edit this article or . Anonymous contributions welcome — no account required.