Bhutanese Community in Idaho

The Bhutanese community in Idaho consists of Lhotshampa refugees and their American-born children, resettled to the state from camps in eastern Nepal under the United States contribution to the third-country resettlement programme that began in 2008. Idaho is not among the largest Bhutanese-American population centres — the community is dwarfed by those in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Texas and Georgia — but resettlement has been continuous since the late 2000s and the community is anchored in two distinct areas: the Boise metropolitan area in the south-west, and the Magic Valley town of Twin Falls in south-central Idaho.

Idaho's Bhutanese population entered national news in 2025, when Binod Shah, a Twin Falls business owner who had lived in the state since 2008, was detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and deported to Bhutan despite being formally stateless. The case became one of the most closely documented in the wave of detentions and removals of Nepali-speaking Bhutanese refugees that began in March 2025.

Population and geography

No state or federal agency publishes a Bhutanese-specific population figure for Idaho. The Idaho Office for Refugees, the state-level coordinating body funded through the federal Office of Refugee Resettlement, reports refugee arrivals only by year and country of origin and does not break out resettled refugees who have since moved within the United States. Independent estimates from community members and resettlement workers place the Idaho Bhutanese population at several hundred to perhaps a thousand people, concentrated in two clusters:

Ada and Canyon Counties — the Boise metropolitan area, including Boise, Meridian, Nampa and Caldwell, where the bulk of Idaho's refugee resettlement has taken place since the 1970s.
Twin Falls County — the city of Twin Falls in the Magic Valley, served by a separate resettlement office and characterised by employment in dairy, food processing and small business.

A handful of Bhutanese families also live in Idaho Falls, Pocatello and Lewiston, but the presence in those cities is too small to constitute an organised community.

Resettlement history

Idaho has one of the longer continuous refugee-resettlement histories of any small US state. The International Rescue Committee has operated in Boise since the late 1970s, when it was established to resettle Vietnamese, Laotian and Cambodian arrivals after the fall of Saigon, and is one of the IRC's longest-running American field offices. The Agency for New Americans (ANA), the second Boise resettlement agency, was founded in October 1996 as the local affiliate of Episcopal Migration Ministries and operates as a programme of Jannus, Inc., a Boise-based non-profit formerly known as the Mountain States Group. In Twin Falls, refugee resettlement is run through the College of Southern Idaho Refugee Center, opened in 1980, which since 2017 has resettled clients in partnership with the U.S. Committee for Refugees and Immigrants (USCRI).

The first Bhutanese refugees from the seven UNHCR camps in Jhapa and Morang districts of eastern Nepal arrived in the United States in March 2008, following a 2007 announcement by Assistant Secretary of State Ellen Sauerbrey that Washington would accept up to 60,000 Lhotshampa for resettlement. Idaho's Bhutanese arrivals began in 2009 and continued at a steady but modest pace through the closure of the Nepal-based programme in 2018. Of the roughly 3,700 refugees of all nationalities resettled to Idaho between 2009 and 2014, Iraqis, Iranians and Bhutanese collectively made up about a quarter of arrivals, alongside larger contingents from the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Burma and Somalia.

Most Idaho Bhutanese reached the state through the Boise resettlement pipeline, with smaller numbers placed directly into Twin Falls. As is typical of resettlement nationally, secondary migration has shifted some families both into and out of Idaho. A portion of those originally placed in Idaho later moved to larger Bhutanese hubs in Pittsburgh, Columbus, Atlanta or Dallas-Fort Worth in search of employment, kinship networks or Hindu religious infrastructure; some Bhutanese families also arrived in Idaho after initial placement elsewhere.

Twin Falls and the 2015–2016 refugee controversy

Twin Falls, a city of about 50,000, has hosted the College of Southern Idaho Refugee Center since 1980. The centre resettles roughly 300 refugees a year and provides eight months of case management covering English instruction, employment, housing and medical care. In 2015 and 2016 it became the focus of an unusually intense local political fight over refugee resettlement, sparked by reports that the centre might receive Syrian arrivals after the Paris attacks of November 2015.

An organised opposition campaign, the Committee to End the CSI Refugee Center, was led by Buhl-area conservative activist Rick Martin, a former Ron Paul campaign organiser. The committee attempted to qualify a county ballot measure to shut down the centre, but by the April 2016 deadline had collected only 894 of the 3,842 signatures required. A separate sexual-assault incident at the Fawnbrook Apartments in June 2016, involving a juvenile of refugee background, was widely amplified on national right-wing media platforms including Breitbart and Infowars and provoked weeks of harassment of refugee families and resettlement staff. In April 2017 the Twin Falls City Council unanimously declared Twin Falls a "welcoming city".

The 2015–16 controversy centred on Syrian and Muslim arrivals rather than on Bhutanese refugees, and Bhutanese families do not feature in the contemporary press coverage of the dispute. Even so, the episode shaped the local political environment in which Twin Falls Bhutanese have lived since, and several community members later said it made them more cautious about public visibility. Director Zeze Rwasama, a Congolese refugee who has run the CSI centre since 2003, was widely praised by both supporters and the city council for keeping the programme operating through the controversy.

Community life

Idaho's Bhutanese community is too small to support its own dedicated cultural institutions on the scale found in Pennsylvania, Ohio or Texas. Hindu families, who make up the majority, generally worship at the Boise Hindu Temple, an Indian-American-led congregation in west Boise that also serves the broader Nepali-speaking diaspora. The Boise Nepalese Association, founded by older Nepali immigrants and graduate students, organises Dashain and Tihar gatherings that draw both Nepali nationals and Bhutanese refugees. Christian Bhutanese, a significant minority in many Lhotshampa resettlement communities, attend a range of evangelical and mainline Protestant churches in Boise and Twin Falls, several of which were active in early refugee co-sponsorship.

The Idaho community has not, as of early 2026, established a registered Bhutanese-American mutual-assistance association comparable to the Bhutanese Community Association of Pittsburgh or the Bhutanese Community Association of Columbus. Community organising tends to flow through informal kinship networks, the Boise Nepalese Association and the resettlement agencies' alumni programmes.

Economic integration

Bhutanese workers in Idaho cluster in the same low-wage entry sectors as elsewhere in the United States — meat and food processing, hospitality, warehousing, building cleaning and home health care — but with a stronger agricultural component than in most resettlement states. The Magic Valley around Twin Falls is one of the largest dairy-producing regions in the United States, and Idaho's significant potato, sugar-beet and food-processing industries (including the Chobani yogurt plant in Twin Falls and the Lamb Weston and Glanbia operations elsewhere in the state) have hired refugee labour at scale since the 1990s. Some Bhutanese families have moved from initial wage employment into small businesses including auto repair, convenience retail and restaurants. Younger Bhutanese-Idahoans have entered Boise State University, the University of Idaho and the College of Southern Idaho, with smaller numbers reaching Idaho State University and Northwest Nazarene University.

The Binod Shah deportation, 2025

In 2025 Idaho's Bhutanese community became a national news story through the case of Binod Shah, a Twin Falls business owner and father in his early forties. Shah was born in southern Bhutan, expelled with his family at the age of four or five during the early-1990s ethnic cleansing of the Lhotshampa, and spent more than a decade in a refugee camp in eastern Nepal before being resettled to the United States in his early twenties. He moved to Twin Falls in 2008 and built a small business with his wife, Stephanie Shah, an American citizen.

In 2018 Shah pleaded guilty to aggravated assault after a fight with his then-wife (a previous marriage). He served roughly seven months in custody before his release on probation in April 2019, after which deportation proceedings were initiated. Bhutan does not recognise Shah as a citizen, having stripped him of nationality in the early 1990s, and the country had until 2025 consistently refused to issue travel documents for stateless Lhotshampa removed from the United States. Successive ICE administrations therefore allowed Shah and other Bhutanese refugees in similar situations to remain in the country under orders of supervision.

In March 2025, under enforcement priorities issued by the second Trump administration, Shah was ordered to report for removal. Local supporters in Twin Falls — including evangelical pastors, business associates and members of the Magic Valley refugee community — organised a defence campaign that included a GoFundMe drive run by Immigrants Allies and a Change.org petition. Coverage by the Magic Valley Times-News, KTVB, the Idaho Statesman, East Idaho News, the Spokesman-Review, Boise State Public Radio and The Guardian turned the case into a national flashpoint about the deportation of stateless refugees to a country that had never agreed to accept them. Shah was deported in November 2025; his wife reported receiving a phone call from him from New Delhi after Bhutanese authorities, according to his account, refused to admit him at the airport and drove him to the Indian border.

Shah's removal was one of at least thirteen confirmed 2025 deportations of Bhutanese refugees from the United States to Bhutan documented by Asian Refugees United (ARU), the San Francisco-based advocacy network co-founded by Lhotshampa community organiser Robin Gurung, and was the only such case originating in Idaho. ARU and the Asian Law Caucus filed a Freedom of Information Act request in late 2025 seeking ICE records on all Bhutanese arrests and deportations.

State political environment

Idaho is one of the most consistently Republican states in the country, and has been governed by Republican governors continuously since 1995, including C.L. "Butch" Otter (2007–2019) and Brad Little (2019–). Both administrations broadly cooperated with the federal refugee resettlement programme through Idaho Office for Refugees funding pass-throughs, even as state-level politics around immigration grew more restrictive after 2016. In 2025, Governor Little publicly committed Idaho State Police resources to assist ICE in transporting people in immigration custody out of the state, framed as targeting "dangerous criminal aliens"; the Department of Homeland Security separately announced a joint enforcement operation with Idaho in June 2025. Local political tensions in Twin Falls and Coeur d'Alene have at times made Bhutanese and other refugee families reluctant to draw public attention to themselves, particularly during the 2015–16 controversy and again during the 2025 ICE wave.

Coverage and documentation gaps

Idaho-specific reporting on the Bhutanese community is thin compared with the coverage available for the much larger Pittsburgh, Columbus and Akron diasporas. Most of what is in print appears in regional outlets — the Idaho Statesman, the Idaho Press, the Magic Valley Times-News, KTVB, KIVI, Boise State Public Radio and Idaho Education News — and tends to surface only around resettlement-policy stories or, more recently, the Binod Shah deportation. Academic research on Idaho's refugee populations has focused on the Boise School District's English-learner programmes and on Twin Falls demographics, with comparatively little ethnographic work on the Bhutanese specifically. Population estimates, organisational membership and even the number of Bhutanese-headed households in the state therefore rest largely on community knowledge rather than published data.

Bhutanese Community in Idaho

Population and geography

Resettlement history

Twin Falls and the 2015–2016 refugee controversy

Community life

Economic integration

The Binod Shah deportation, 2025

State political environment

Coverage and documentation gaps

See also

References

Test Your Knowledge

Help improve this article